News: Apple & Samsung Bring Design Patents to the Supreme Court for the First Time 130 Years
Samsung and Apple are back in court, but this time it's not just money at stake. The Supreme Court's decision could have a far reaching effect on patent law and innovation in design. Smartphone design timeline. Image via Samsung v Apple court document The so-called "Smartphone Patent Wars" began in 2011 when Apple sued Samsung (then the supplier of some Apple components), alleging that the South Korean company had infringed on patents and trademarks for everything from the look and build of the iPhone right down to the color design of the iPhone's user interface. The design elements in question are the rectangular face and round edges, the bezel frame, and the apps layout on the home screen.Don't Miss: The 68 Coolest New iOS 10 Features You Didn't Know AboutJust to clarify, a design patent only covers "any new, original and ornamental design for an article of manufacture." Meaning that if a design is copied, it's reasonable to assume that it was copied in order to fool consumers and not because the product won't work without it.At this point nobody is arguing that Samsung didn't copy Apple's design. That's a given. What Samsung ostensibly wants now is to lower the amount of money that they would have to pay Apple by a few hundred million. While that is a good chunk of cash for most of us, it's nothing for a company like Samsung—or Apple for that matter. So why is this such a big deal? The Supreme Court doesn't usually hear cases about design patents—so their decision on this could set a new precedent.
Design Patents and the Supreme CourtThe original precedent for this sort of case was set nearly 130 years ago when John and James Dobson started copying carpet designs to sell their cheap carpets. Two of the companies whose designs were copied, Hartford Carpet Co. and Bigelow Carpet, brought the case to the Supreme Court and argued that they were entitled to any profits the Dobsons had made from the bootlegged products.Unfortunately for Hartford and Bigelow, the Court couldn't decide whether it was appropriate to award the total amount of any profits earned solely on the basis of design. The idea being that people are ultimately buying carpets for how well they function as carpets, not because they look pretty. Big Carpet was not happy and ended up lobbying Congress to amend the Patent Act to place more importance on design patents.Fast forward to the 21st century. It's the same basic issue—to what degree does a product's design contribute to its success in the marketplace—but the products in question are way more complex than floor coverings. What the Justices have to decide after hearing arguments this week is whether consumers were buying Samsung phones mostly because they looked just like iPhones, or mostly because they were functional phones—but like also a tiny bit because they looked just like iPhones.
Why Smartphones Are DifferentNow, you might be asking why haven't any other lawsuits over design infringement made it to the Supreme Court in so long? While there are plenty of knock-off products around, and designers do sue over these infringements, but most of these cases are settled out of court. The problem here is that the smartphone designs aren't a question of a faux logo or a cheap handbag. As objects go, smartphones are some of the most complex in history, and it's hard to say which of the hundreds of thousands of parts and patents it takes to build one are most responsible for consumer interest.As Ronald Mann, Supreme Court of the United States Blog contributor, explains:"Samsung's central argument on that point is one of policy: Given the hundreds (if not thousands) of innovative elements that go into a modern cellphone, it makes little sense to award all of Samsung's profits because a few of those elements infringe. Even granting the importance of the screen and interface to the phones' success, Samsung argues, surely they aren't the source of all of the company's profits from the phones." Samsung phones before iPhone. Image via Samsung v Apple court document But let's be real here. Do you remember when the iClones started popping up? Before Samsung copied Apple's designs, the iPhone was in a league of its own. It was the accessory of luxury. Owners of iPhones used to put them down on counters and tables in the same way people flash metal American Express black cards. Samsung phones after iPhone. Image via Samsung v Apple court document So, yes, people were buying Samsung's phones because they needed phones—but of course they were buying them because they looked like iPhones. If not for that, Samsung may have gone the way of BlackBerry. At least, that's Apple's side of it. The Cupertino company argues that before the Galaxy S, Samsung's market share was tanking. And then: Samsung market share 2006-2012. Note: 2009 was also the year that Samsung started selling smartphones with the Android operating system. Image via Apple v Samsung Court Document On the other hand, the fact that the physical characteristics of most smartphones are basically interchangeable forces companies to innovate with every product cycle (or at least try). And this isn't just about smartphones, either. As Hamza Shaban, writing for BuzzFeed News, puts it:"A victory for Apple could lead to absurd scenarios, in which a company that infringes on a tiny percentage of another firm's design could be held liable for 100% of its profits. This is like a car company being forced to hand over its earnings because it copied someone else's design for a backseat cup holder, Samsung has suggested. The company fears that a ruling in favor of Apple would breed a new class of patent troll, especially in the realm of technology where products are made up of thousands of complex parts, in addition to their design features.Apple, in turn, claims more than 100 design professionals as allies, including Calvin Klein and Alexander Wang. The designers urged the court to consider that, in the minds of consumers, design often represents the product itself."
What's It All Mean?So in Samsung's mind, we could be looking at a crazy future with no aesthetic zeitgeist where every aspect of every product must be differentiated from those of every competitor. Ok. Maybe that's a bit too far, but at the very least a "polo shirt" would have to be a Polo shirt, or else.Regardless of the Court's eventual ruling, due in June 2017, the case is an important one and long overdue. The products we're talking about aren't just fancy accessories, they're practically inseparable from the way that many people conduct modern life both personally and professionally. Allowing one company to be in a position to dictate what that looks like would be irresponsible, and it's sort of appropriate that we have Apple largely to thank for that.Follow Gadget Hacks on Facebook, Twitter, Google+, and YouTube Follow Android Hacks on Facebook, Twitter, and Pinterest Follow WonderHowTo on Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, and Google+
44 | The Hackers Manual 2016. May 2000 Linux Format #1 Renaming the title in line with Futures most successful print magazines: Amiga Format and PC Format, Linux Format was released with editor Nick Veitch of Amiga Format fame and writing talent from PC Plus mag. It came with a CD and was an instant hit. Enjoy software freedom. Discover Linux!
16 Hidden Apple TV Features You Should Know Here are the tips and tricks you need to know to get the most out of your Apple TV. By Chandra Steele and Jason Cohen
5 Hidden Windows 10 Features You Should Use - gizmodo.com
You will need a device which is capable of storing all of the data you need to back up. This should be at least twice the size of the hard drive you are trying to back up. An external hard drive is the best option, and these are easy to find. It is also possible to create a partition, if you wish to use your current computer as a backup. You
How to open htc backup file? - Techyv.com
The on screen keyboard pops up and I never use it because of the PKB of course. I guess some people needed it on the Priv bc the PKB issues. But now it blocks your text captions on snaps. Is there a way to disable it for the app? Absolutely love how smooth snapchat is on the KEYone by the way. Totally awesome!
How do I toggle the virtual keyboard? - BlackBerry Forums at
Given how much use it gets on a daily basis, the power button is always one of the first hardware features to call it quits on an Android phone or tablet. So if your power button is acting up, or you don't want it to, you can extend its lifetime by simply finding ways to use it less.
How to restart your Android without working power button
How do I unfriend or remove a friend? | Facebook Help Center
This is how I process my DSLR photos using VSCO on my iPhone! Gear used to take the photos: Canon 6D -
"If your children ignore your repeated calls and text messages to reach them, you simply lock their phones until they call you back," says the description of the app. "When you lock your child's phone with Ignore No More your child has only two options - he or she can call you back, or call for an emergency responder.
Mom Creates App That Forces Children to Respond to Their
My phone shows "line in use", but all handsets are cradled or off - Answered by a verified Electronics Technician We use cookies to give you the best possible experience on our website. By continuing to use this site you consent to the use of cookies on your device as described in our cookie policy unless you have disabled them.
How to view errors for "device disabled"? NW 7.6 - Dell Community
6 Instagram Hacks for Better Instagram Stories by Jenn Herman on Social Media Examiner. #1: Customize Font Colors. To add text to your Instagram stories, tap the Aa icon in the top-right corner when you take or upload a photo or video to your story. In the keyboard that opens, select from a range of colors. There are actually infinite color
Creative Secrets of Instagram Stories | Instagram for Business
If you're like me, just the idea of skydiving triggers nearly-pee-in-the-pants petrification. But with a little imagination, plus Google Image Search and a projector, and all of us ninnies out there can pretend to do the real thing: "All it takes to skydive on Google Earth is a projector, some blue tarps with clouds spray painted on, a suspension system, and a bunch of nutballs with giant fans
Skydiving Mishap « Jackass 3D Contest :: WonderHowTo
At the end of an all-day affair with friends or family, I'll unwind and go through all the pictures I took that day as a sort of recap. All too often, though, I'll come across a few that are almost perfect, except I didn't quite position my phone well enough, leaving someone's face cutoff or too much space to one side of the image.
How to Take Timed Photos on Android: 13 Steps (with Pictures)
0 comments:
Post a Comment